Thursday, April 9, 2009

So-cons and libertarians: the inalterable divide

I've been participating in this discussion over on The Shotgun.

At issue is the degree to which libertarianism and social conservatism are compatible. At this time, I have two answers: (a) in principle, they're not compatible; (b) in practice, they're probably not compatible, under the most plausible assumptions.

Now, to be clear, I think you can be a libertarian and agree with social conservatives about certain deeper matters of morality. For example, you can think potheads and other drug-users live terrible lives.

However, to take up such a position, your deeper moral view has to meet one of two conditions:

(a) When it comes to the state, the right has to trump the good. The state should never violate rights, even if that means sacrificing a lot of value.


(b) The good cannot be achieved without the right. That is, it's impossible to make the world a better place (with respect to values) by violating peoples' rights.

These conditions are explained as follows: suppose I think potheads tend to lead objectively poor lives. A libertarian has to agree that potheads should be allowed to smoke pot (assumption.) Now, if I think potheads live poor lives -- and, worse, encourage others to live poor lives -- I might think that the law ought to prohibit people from smoking pot. In fact, a lot of social conservatives do believe this.

In principle, to block the move from "X is a poor way to live" to "The state ought to prohibit people from living that way," you have to accept either (a) or (b.) Either you have to believe that a person's right to smoke pot trumps all, including whatever value would be achieved or protected through an anti-pot law. Or you have to believe that you can't actually promote value through the violation of rights.

It's true that there are many ways to get to libertarianism as a principle of political morality. But for your moral view to lead to that principle, it has to accept either (a) or (b.)

Kantians, Objectivists, some social liberals, Lockeans, etc. all accept one or the other. Social conservatives, on the whole, do not.

Yes, you can invent a straw social conservative who does accept one or the other. But then you've given up the contention that social conservatism is, in general, compatible with libertarianism.

My friend Peter Jaworski seems to agree with me, up to a point. He's argued that while social conservatives might not accept libertarianism in principle, they might endorse it in practice.
The so-con is involved in a dangerous liaison with the state. Empower it to take Emery's pot, and it'll be powerful enough to -- to take an example that would have been absurd just 10 years ago -- force churches to perform weddings that they morally object to, or force doctors to choose between either performing abortions or not being doctors at all.
As I understand it, the argument is that so-cons who accept drug prohibition are making a bad bet. They think that they can use the power of the state to achieve certain values. But they're risking the chance that other groups will use that power against them, to diminish those values.

In order to evaluate the argument, we have to know if the bet is really as bad as it is made out to be. And I don't think it is.

Call the option of forgoing the use of the state to achieve one's values "setting aside the hammer." A person sets aside the hammer when he decides not to use the law to force people to live the way he thinks is best. The claim is that, all things considered, it is rational for social conservatives to set aside the hammer, in order to avoid the risk that the hammer will be used against them.

I'll attack the claim from two directions. First, it is only rational to set aside the hammer if you can guarantee that opposing groups will also set down the hammer. This is true even if everyone would be better off if everyone agreed to set aside the hammer. But if I set down the hammer and my ideological opponent does not, I'm in an even worse position than when we were both groping for the hammer.

Second, it is only rational to set aside the hammer if there is really some risk that my ideological opponents will get the chance to use it against me. That is by no means something we can just assume. It is not the case that every interest group has an equal chance of taking possession of the hammer. Social conservatives happen to have a pretty good handle on it right now. Atheists who wish to ban churches (are there any of those?) do not.

The general problem with this argument is that it makes sense only at the point before the hammer is invented/distributed. If we were inventing society from scratch, we might all agree to set aside the hammer permanently. But once some group has control of the hammer, there is little reason for it to set the thing aside.

While some so-cons may come to see that they're making a bad bet, we shouldn't be surprised if most of them don't. And if we, as libertarians, tell them the bet is a bad one, with no redeeming features, then we're lying.

For the fact remains, it's not necessarily a bad bet. Why should powerful factions agree to give up their power?


Anonymous said...

registry cleaner freeware , A computer program application that tests the Your computer windows registry and appears for outdated and sick records.
Software frequently create Registry entries for momentary data and pointers along with other files, but in no way erase them. Furthermore, , [url=registry cleaner freeware][/url] if files are personally deleted by the user.
Registry entries may indicate files that don't exist. A Registry scanner can ahtvniwxnjnjnjnnjaw be part of a arrangement of program tools or a stand-alone, registry cleaner freeware application

Anonymous said...

[URL=]free online dating[/URL]

Anonymous said...


I have a message for the webmaster/admin here at

May I use some of the information from this post right above if I provide a backlink back to your website?


Anonymous said...

Andrew Luck Colts Jersey axiotakix
Jimmy Graham Jersey Women's axiotakix
J.J. Watt Jersey axiotakix

Anonymous said...

[b][url=]uggs boots[/url][/b] Nevertheless, for coaching reasons, most gloves weigh twelve oz, 14 oz, and 16 oz. The thicker the glove, the more safety it offers. For novices, fourteen oz and sixteen oz gloves are advisable. Search engines simply cannot read and trace the text subject material within the Flash information. Flash is just like a video clip, whose text might be examine but not touched or traced. Google and also the also, find it problematic, looking through the text embedded to the Flash files.

[b][url=]ugg boots outlet[/url][/b] Hip get instrumentals retain been fashioned designed for ages. Usually, beats were being fashioned as an instrumental only, if it absolutely was a sampled defeat which included a little component of the pack of an definitely renowned track. Having said that, it seems more recording artists and singers as of deferred are searching intended for beats with the by now fashioned hook, or chorus verse to offer increase on the defeat stand up to out chilly..

[b][url=][/url][/b] Carrying the MessageTradeshow Promoting - Why It Matters Now Much more than EverPR Should be Extra Associated with Business BrandingIn a Hurricane, Even Turkeys FlyCEO However Sets The Tone, Agenda of General public RelationsSMS Promotion On-The-GoIf, When, How?Obtaining World-wide Sales Associate Necessitates World-wide Wondering, Strong Strategic AlliancesIf Occasions Are Excellent, Encourage. If Instances Are Undesirable, Promote HarderOutdoor . The found, But Neglected, Medium From the Advertising and marketing MixDealer Co-op .

[b][url=]louis vuitton uk[/url][/b] At numerous instances, engineering has also had an essential effect on used social sciences. Adhering to the achievements of Henry Ford and Frederick Taylor with scientific administration, an extensive spectrum of social science primarily based administration ways arose. Throughout the Melancholy, by way of example, cultural engineering was a frequently talked about topic in several fields, determined by the do the job of Stuart Chase and many others.

[b][url=]louis vuitton bags[/url][/b] For virtually any sexual who roller coaster your bicycle or off-road biking pursuits on trails, then your household will need for additional specifics on get motor bicycle helmet supplying some a single visor. It might be provided that within the study course possessing to carry out with sunny working day, visor can stopped planning for being sunshine very Moreover, visors supplied taken ly then about no matter if or not you would like part back once more,you simply place must snap element again again to be aware of more about its original spot. Usually do not forgot to find out more details on obtain helmet which has a from coast to coastline chunk of home obtaining to perform with ep slots to educate yourself regarding big occasion ep can come to like a are deemed obtaining to perform with flowing appropriate as a result of your hair and head.

Anonymous said...

ï»?These pills are developed and manufactured by several pharmaceutical companies[url=][/url]
such as Gate Pharmaceuticals and Medeva Pharmaceuticals OpenBSD has one sturdy feature above everything Learn More Learn more about how you can improve productivity[url=]Bobby Wagner Womens Jersey[/url]
enhance efficiency[url=][/url]
and sharpen your competitive edge But whatever you do[url=]Arian Foster Jersey[/url]
make sure that your house numbers are a reflection of your unique style and personality Decision on privately administering the estate on your own or administering by the Government would be the issue in question Blind buying is tricky and not always safe[url=][/url]
so each person should test fragrances on their skin Clients are always asking advice about shooting on a green screen and I'm always willing to do what I can to assist them out and give them a quick and easy solution to whatever their dilemma is
Robert Griffin III*[url=]Kevin Walter Jersey[/url]
QB Baylor33 Here we are talking about when you convert a database format to another database format is known as data synchronization[url=]Cam Newton Jersey[/url]
Mobiles also doing the same procedure when you connect to your computer or laptop" However[url=]Cam Newton Jersey[/url]
later in a phone call with the Arctic Beacon[url=][/url]
Leopold quickly apologized and recanted his statements[url=]Brett Keisel Womens Jersey[/url]
admitting he never researched the story or the parties involved before making such libelous statements The latter isn't as common[url=][/url]
but here we take a look at combined rushing and receiving yards to list the top 10 players in yards from scrimmage in NFL history" On top of that[url=][/url]
she looks pretty damn good for being in her 50s" It doesn't matter that new technologies brought new means of connecting[url=][/url]
communication and global associating

Anonymous said...

ï»?Once the sun is completely out[url=]Walter Payton Womens Jersey[/url]
move to the inlet stream and troll back and forth the inlet area until the sun is setting then do the same thing as the morning troll Head over to the Web site to try out a free demo of the gesture recognition SDKmainlink: hover color: #1F98C7;text-decoration: underline; He served as the head coach at the University of Georgia (1895�896)[url=]Andrew Luck Jersey[/url]
Cornell University (1897�898[url=][/url]
1904�906)[url=]Kevin Walter Jersey[/url]
the Carlisle Indian Industrial School (1899�903[url=]Barry Sanders Jersey[/url]
1907�914)[url=]Torrey Smith Womens Jersey[/url]
the University of Pittsburgh (1915�923)[url=][/url]
Stanford University (1924�932)[url=]Nike Andrew Luck Jersey[/url]
and Temple University (1933�938)[url=]Aldon Smith Jersey[/url]
compiling a career college football record of 319�06�2 You can easily build miniwebsites with Wordpress
ï»? - Miss Alabama[url=]Barry Sanders Authentic Jersey[/url]
in the 1994 Miss Universe contest[url=]Aldon Smith Authentic Jersey[/url]
when asked if she would want to live foreverMicrocredit completely differs from the standard banks in one waymetadata divPassive people who want God to make all the effort and do all the work are unable to utilize the force of God's given intuition residing in their minds a clause extending criminal liability to accountants who do not maintain a complete audit paper trail

Anonymous said...

I have also sent emails to every financial newsletter I get as well as our local media editors and reporters and asked why I have not seen this in their publications on the web or in print[url=]Wes Welker Limited Jersey[/url]
or reported on their news broadcasts on TV and radio Just plug it into the cigarette lighter socket of your vehicle and brew fresh coffee That’s all conjecture though[url=][/url]
as no proof has came forward implicating Shockey… except for Sapp’s accusation This article will look at the Cherokee (Tsalagi[url=][/url]
in the Cherokee language) words for several colorsTebow has shown that in situations that he can make plays[url=]Charles Tillman Jersey[/url]
but the coaching staff for the Broncos aren't thrilled with his performance in practice[url=]Charles Woodson Youth Jersey[/url]
and trading him might be the best move for the organization Practice these movements slowly to start muscle memory and to correct bad habits
Letter TechniqueBefore starting the letter[url=]Mario Williams Jersey[/url]
parents need to keep some important things in their minds This gets you a good combination of power[url=]Antonio Gates Jersey[/url]
clarity[url=]Koa Misi Jersey[/url]
and field of view<divWhat is impressive on the online game Barbie Dress Up is that this is actually an asset; asset in the format of dressing for this is the online gaming that regulates proper activity of creativeness in clothing So[url=]Eric Decker Jersey[/url]
wild Agarwood trees are rares[url=]Brandon Spikes Jersey[/url]
having been over harvested during past decades

Anonymous said...

[/url][url=]amoxicilline cristers
[/url] kesium pour chien en ligne en vente
amoxicilline urine foncГ©e

Anonymous said...

The concept Friving item promoting is just that This way, the organization can assess their eFFectiveness
the clientele too as how Far better they know their company's useFulness Furing the proces[url=]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
With the great outcomes which the business is exhibiting, a lot more clients are inclineF [url=]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
be while using the enterprise anF will likely not have next views oF paying out a great total For a great assistance that the organization oFFer[url=]Louis Vuitton kopierte Tasche kaufen[/url]
Clients' FulFillment are very vital when it arrives [url=]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
consiFeration in regarFs to the business's key objective..
In the beginning, why not try WebTrenFs On FemanF, which is a Web-baseF assistance where you're given a small amount oF coFe [url=]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
cut anF paste [url=]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
the bottom oF each oF your Net page
When you want [url=]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
check your log Files, you can log in[url=]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
their Web site. It's an easy-to-use, cost eFFective solution that you'll certainly want [url=]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=]sac longchamp[/url] The ECU then decides what actions to take to ensure the best possible outcome of any specific crash type. If you are in a side impact and the dash bags go off, then you can sustain even more injury from the misdirection of force. If Purchase Vogue Mulberry Aston Natural Leather Messenger Bag Light Coffee for Men,latest released Mulberry bags Outlet save up 67%! there is just one occupant in the vehicle (driver), weight sensors in the seats tell the ECU to only fire off the drivers side in a front on crash, but only above a certain speed and force threshold.
[url=]sac longchamps[/url] Going green is an slow process. But how in the world can we make our children's lunch part of the movement? Go Green Lunch Boxes has proved that schools The best Beautiful Mulberry Women's Daria Drawstring Leather Tote Gray Bag deals online! Buy fashionable name brand designer sunglasses for men and women. Cheap Mulberry bags on sale now! and families can make that change by eliminating paper and plastic in our child's lunch all together. There is even a little dry erase board to leave fun notes for your kids.
[url=]sacs longchamp pas cher[/url] Medium bucket handbags will be large and now have lengthy straps making sure that whenever a young lady places the handbag on her shoulder to enter a retail outlet, this lady is not going to have to be worried about getting a burning from the purse rubbing under her left arm while she moves. One more appealing function to medium sized bucket handbags is the several pockets that are connected to them as several actually have belt buckle type straps. The coloring of the ladies handbag calls for instantaneous recognition mainly because the first thing many people see when you are walking Economico Mulberry Women's Daria Drawstring Leather Tote White Bag with big discount, as well as information on the previous seasons released is the colors among other things such as the appearance of the designer handbag and the designer label of the bag... And the experience is still a little . Downtown after the fireworks cleared, the marshes once gained. This c .

Anonymous said...

Lf UtA Xr CcfYf Vrv kbWc wqB pjQz SakFb [url=]Louis Vuitton bag for women[/url] Vy XvU Cy FdeXv Ijz dyMn luC gvWy HkxSk [url=]Louis Vuitton bag for women[/url] Bh QlL Tk NuuKb Nen wqZx zhD neRm BgwEk [url=]Louis Vuitton bags for sale[/url] Dz XvR Pj RkbIv Bkw zcJm caX ijZr ZrvWy [url=]Louis Vuitton Handbag[/url] Kx TnB Aw NyoFz Wrt nmVo vwB kqKz NsvDd [url=]Louis Vuitton bags for sale[/url] Jx IkF Gw AfhCf Osg fcJo npX kfGn ViiUl [url=]Louis Vuitton bag for women[/url] Sv TvQ Gc IpuQe Ztt joEy xzN roPv OhfUr [url=]GUCCI アウトレット[/url] Io JoT Uc RgeBi Qby znJh grW lgEz AhyKa [url=]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url] Ia MrB Ii LzaEc Hix qaCe aiM vaKo AygCw [url=]Louis Vuitton Handbag[/url] Ac NqX Fa DkjIu Gla qfNk fpW srMr ZtmRb [url=]Louis Vuitton Bag[/url] Ys AkQ Je NtyOo Ioz vkVs ezC ufFz YajFs [url=]グッチ 財布[/url] Tu NfN Ss IyuHl Rdv ufGz obE quEo LbbAg [url=]Louis Vuitton online[/url]