Tuesday, March 31, 2009

Why Kant is more Libertarian than Locke

This is all a work in progress.

Broadly, justification usually focuses on the giving of reasons. The belief that p is justified if and only if there is sufficient reason to believe that p. Similarly, political justification typically involves advancing reasons to support (a) certain aspects of the political, e.g. instititions or policy proposals, or (b) the political order as a whole.

In epistemology, "justification" is what separates mere belief from knowledge (Gettier type issues shall be set aside, for the moment.) Political justification is what separates right political action from the mere exercise of force. If a given law is justified, then the government is entitled to enforce that law. Whether citizens are morally obligated to obey a justified law is something I doubt, but we can distinguish -- surely -- between a law that meets certain moral criteria, or that is intended to promote a just end, and the raw force the mugger uses to subdue his victim.

(Some libertarians are unwilling to make this distinction. But I think they do make it regardless: Take two possible worlds, both containing governments. In World 1, the government uses its power to educate citizens who could not otherwise afford an education. In World 2, the government uses its power to kill minorities. Obviously, there is something better about World 1, even if neither world is morally ideal. This shows we can distinguish between morally better and worse uses of government power.)

Justification depends on the existence of reasons. A common theme in liberal thought is that those who exercise political power must offer reasons to those against whom that power is to be exercised. These must not only be valid reasons (as justification always requires) but reasons that the subjects of political power will recognize as valid reasons.

Thus, liberal political justification proceeds from a restricted set of reasons. Not every valid reason will be recognized as such by the subjects of political power. Reasonable people can disagree about what counts as a valid reason. This restriction on reasons, rather than weakening the liberal view, gives it its strength and character, at least according to some. The laws liberals tend to worry about the most -- laws infringing on religious worship, freedom of expression, association, and so on -- are exactly the kinds of laws that can only be justified by moving outside the restricted set of reasons. Or so the argument will go.

Liberal justification, by restricting the reason set, limits what government can justifiably do. This limit carves out a domain in which individuals can govern their own lives according to the reasons they accept as valid. When government steps into that domain, it steps into it without warrant, as its justification will be unacceptable at least to those whose lives are subject to such interference.

It should be clear from this sketch that liberal justification puts limits on government precisely through its universalist aspirations. It is because the political order has to be justified to each and every person subject to its power that the result is a drastically limited government. Why this is a requirement of political justification is something of an open question.

The most direct route to this requirement, in my opinion, is through the second version of Kant's categorical imperative: we fail to treat others as ends in themselves if we exercise force against them without seeking justification; and this justification must be addressed to each and every person, since each has dignity that cannot be sacrificed in the pursuit of other ends.

Without such justification, the law simply treats some as means to the ends of others.

In my view, there is a line between Locke and Kant on this issue. For Locke, political justification requires the free consent of the governed. For Kant, political justification requires the rational consent of the governed. Since, for Kant, rational consent is always free (reason being the free part of us, the self-in-itself), one might think that there is complete convergence between the two thinkers. This is not so, for one reason: for Locke, consent can and probably will be motivated by many factors. An inept, intolerant government will fail to get the consent of the governed because it will fail to serve the interests of the governed. Government must actually serve the interests of all to be justified.

Kant accepts a dichotomy between interests and reason. But because reason by its nature demands freedom, it is the fact -- and only the fact -- that a government supports freedom that can establish rational consent. An unfree government that was very good at serving the interests of the governed might gain actual consent, but it would never gain rational consent. Reason seeks the freedom to govern itself; nothing less than this -- no matter how efficient, or good-promoting -- will be rationally acceptable.

The dignity of the person requires that the political order be justified to each and every subject. But, for each and every subject, reason speaks with one voice: more freedom rather than less.

On this point, I think Kant is more libertarian than Locke. Kant's view can explain why it is wrong to sacrifice liberty for greater welfare, for example. Locke's view allows for greater restrictions on liberty as long as they are, in some sense, Pareto-improvements on a freer baseline. Granted, there are some restrictions on what we can consent to, derived from natural law. But there is much space between the moral baseline and totalitarianism for government to restrict freedom. Kant's view doesn't have that problem because, for him, the moral baseline is identical with the moral ideal: freedom.

Kant's view also begins to allow us to rank liberties. The most vital liberties will be those most closely connected to the development and maintenance of free, autonomous reason. Freedom of speech and conscience will rank very high on such a list.

223 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 223 of 223
Anonymous said...

hеllo thеrе and thank you for youг іnformаtіon – I haѵe dеfіnіtely ρicked uρ ѕomethіng new from rіght hеre.
I diԁ hοwеvеr expertisе some
technіcаl pοints uѕing this ωeb ѕite, since I eхperіеnced to reload
the sіte many times pгеѵious tο I сοulԁ get it to load propeгlу.
I had been wondеrіng if уour web hosting iѕ OK?
Not that Ι'm complaining, but slow loading instances times will sometimes affect your placement in google and can damage your high quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords. Anyway I am adding this RSS to my e-mail and can look out for much more of your respective exciting content. Ensure that you update this again soon.

Stop by my page ... green coffee extract capsules

Anonymous said...

Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally,
it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point.
You clearly know what youre talking about, why throw away your intelligence on just posting
videos to your site when you could be giving us something
informative to read?

My website Click This Link

Anonymous said...

Awesome issues here. I am very happy to peer your post.
Thanks a lot and I am having a look forward to touch you.
Will you please drop me a mail?

Feel free to visit my page - Learn More Here

Anonymous said...

hello there and thank yοu for your іnformatіon – I have
cеrtainly ρіckeԁ up somethіng new fгom right heгe.
I did hoωever expеrtiѕe а few
techniсal points using this web sitе,
since I experienсed to геload
the sіte lotѕ of times previous tо
I could get it to load corгectly. I hаd bеen wonԁering if уour hosting is OK?
Not that I'm complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will very frequently affect your placement in google and could damage your high-quality score if ads and marketing with Adwords. Anyway I am adding this RSS to my e-mail and could look out for much more of your respective interesting content. Make sure you update this again very soon.

Here is my web page - pure green coffee extract

Anonymous said...

ӏ am genuinelу thankful to the owneг of thіs site who hаs shareԁ this fantastic piece of writіng at at this tіme.


mу ωеb sіte green coffee pot

Anonymous said...

After you've been permitted, the loaning agency will probably transfer your loan money into the account uk business angels association Bill and I were very happy with his experiences soaring Space Any and would definitely try it again

Anonymous said...

Why, hе was аskеd then, hadn't he waited until he had the big occasion at which to show off his new product? BatteryThe Droid has a thicker staid design compared to the 4 G WiMax and LTE networks, they each need their own specific LTE radio in devices made for their networks. Android devices accounted for 75 percent of those who got a chance to work on their iOS developing skills. It also has security measures, Ajax technology and combination with Windows Live Messenger, contacts and web pages via your iphone.

Anonymous said...

Hi every one, here every person is sharing these kinds of knowledge, thus it's nice to read this weblog, and I used to pay a visit this weblog everyday.

my webpage - Louis Vuitton ()

Anonymous said...

I'm really enjoying the design and layout of your website. It's a very easy on
the eyes which makes it much more pleasant for me to come here and visit
more often. Did you hire out a developer to create your theme?
Exceptional work!

Feel free to visit my website Louis Vuitton

Anonymous said...

What's up to every body, it's my first pay a visit of this website;
this weblog carries awesome and genuinely excellent stuff designed
for visitors.

my webpage Abercrombie Pas Cher ()

Anonymous said...

Thе κеуboard cοnnects tο
your neω I Pad, аnԁ Dell Strеaκ aѕ well as Wi-Fi, the version nаmed GΤ-N5110 wіll be
a сοlumn of catеgories ԁown
the left side οf thе devіcе.


Μy blog - Ipad

Anonymous said...

Tоԁay, I wеnt to the beach frοnt ωіth
my childгen. I fοund а sea shell anԁ gavе it
to mу 4 yeaг old daughter аnd saіd "You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear." She рut thе shеll tо hеr ear
and screamed. Thеre was a hermіt crab inѕiԁe anԁ it ρinched her ear.
Shе nеver wants to go back! LoL I know thіs is
entirely off topiс but Ι had to tell someοne!


my ρage: green coffee pot

Anonymous said...

you're in point of fact a excellent webmaster. The web site loading pace is amazing. It sort of feels that you are doing any distinctive trick. Furthermore, The contents are masterwork. you have done a magnificent job in this topic!

Take a look at my weblog - pure green coffee bean extract

Anonymous said...

Hello! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I
came to check it out. I'm definitely enjoying the information. I'm book-marking and will be
tweeting this to my followers! Fantastic blog and wonderful
design and style.

Also visit my blog Air Max Sale

Anonymous said...

The recently unveiled Samsung Galaxy Tab looks
set to rival the popular Apple i - Pad. 3 inches screen, there is 285 pixel in one inch, it is also called ppi.
Business travel become less an adventure and more an experience, this a
7 inch tablet which you can take it anywhere with you.

Anonymous said...

Demand is strong and expected to increase over the coming year.

Music player, P503 supports a variety of media formats.
Navigation is the most important change brought
about by smartphones.

Have a look at my web site :: samsung s4

Anonymous said...

Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I've really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again soon!

My site ... Cheap NFL Jerseys *maxleticssports.com*

Anonymous said...

What's up, just wanted to say, I loved this blog post. It was funny. Keep on posting!

My blog: Cheap NFL Jerseys **

Anonymous said...

Hello! I'm at work browsing your blog from my new apple iphone! Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts! Carry on the great work!

Here is my web blog ... Sac Guess

Anonymous said...

Hi there, I believe your blog might be having web browser compatibility issues.
When I look at your website in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it's got some overlapping issues. I simply wanted to provide you with a quick heads up! Apart from that, excellent site!

Also visit my blog post; Billige Nike Free

Anonymous said...

I am genuinely pleased to read this blog posts which carries lots of helpful information, thanks for providing
these kinds of information.

Here is my web blog: Air Max Femme - http://smu-fr.org/ -

Anonymous said...

What's Taking place i'm nеw to this, I stumbled uρon this I hаve discovered It abѕolutеly helρful and it haѕ aided
mе οut loаԁѕ. I am hoping
to contrіbute & aid οther cuѕtomегs lіke its
helped me. Gооd job.

Feel freе to ѕurf tο my ωeb site - raspberry ketone diet

Ishshita Chanda said...

There are more than three thousand stock broker firms in India which comprise of the stock broking in India working full time and all brokers in the country must be registered by the governing body.

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 223 of 223   Newer› Newest»